As one of the few fans of Gatewalkers..

I liked it all.

I liked and still like all the PCs. I liked that it was hard and frustrating at times and that the dice and combats were unforgiving.

I liked the deaths.

I like that the players heckle each other, especially during tense moments.

I like that the players had to earn bottle caps rather than getting them for free at the start of each sesh (although a little generosity wouldn't have gone astray. Especially for a joke that lands).

I loved the bants, I loved the interactions of the PCs with each other and the world. I love that Joe has unreasonable opinions about bards and teases relentlessly. I like that it got me fired up and laughing cos i disagreed.

All the above is what made Gatewalkers special in my eyes.

Giantslayer had similar moments of frustration (Ewigga) that were hilarious and reminded me of arguments at our home games.

I'm frustrated that it got canceled.

I know that the majority of you disagree. But I thought i'd post anyways in case there is anyone else that didn't take personal umbrage at how someone else ran a game.