I miss the magic of Left/Right game...what stories do you think live up to that?

Meaning - like, it's my favorite nosleep series ever and I think about it often and wish I could read it with fresh eyes! If you were a huge fan of that series as well, what others (or standalone stories) have grabbed you in the same way?

https://www.reddit.com/r/nosleep/comments/7asz8x/has_anyone_heard_of_the_leftright_game_part_1/

EDIT: Just wanted to say THANK YOU for alll the suggestions, you've given me lots to comb through everyone and I really appreciate it!